“Ms. McNulty is stellar in her portrayal of each character. It’s fitting that she both opens and closes this production, passionately playing so many women of different ages and experiences.”

-Colin Douglas, on McNulty’s performance in Title X with Artemisia Theatre. – Chicago Theatre Review

“…everyone’s work is absolutely stellar. McNulty [and Cheng] are brilliant, slipping into disparate characters as easily as changing Jessica VanWinkle’s excellent costumes”

-Sarz Maxwell on McNulty’s performance in Title X with Artemisia Theatre.

“Melanie McNulty did a superb job of bringing out the strengths of everyone, with the staging being just a backyard works great for a small theatre.”

-Frank Meccia on McNulty’s direction for Cry It Out at Theatre Above the Law – All Around the Town Chicago

“McNulty especially navigates the tragedy of Marianne’s arc in the latter half of the play with all the seriousness and groundedness it deserves.”

-Ben Kaye, on McNulty’s performance in Constellations at Theatre Above the Law, New City Stage

“Theatre Above the Law’s dynamic acting foursome under the direction of Melanie McNulty brings Metzler’s charming work to life.”

-Amanda Finn, on McNulty’s direction for Cry It Out at Theatre Above the Law, Chicago Reader